Skip to main content

Notebook Religion

Scriptures out of stock

(China Photos/Getty Images)


Scriptures out of stock

Bible sales restrictions at online retailers in China are part of the Communist government’s effort to control religion

A search on China’s online retail giant Taobao can help you find items you didn’t think you needed. You can find a snack bowl with grooves to hold your iPhone, a rain poncho that covers two people and a scooter, or a laser-beam taillight for your bike that projects emojis onto the road.

One thing you can no longer find on Taobao: the Bible, the holy Word of God.

Starting in late March, major online retailers including, Dangdang, and stopped offering Bibles for sale, although children’s Bibles, theological books, and Bible concordances remained. Technically, Bibles in China are allowed to be sold only in government-sanctioned churches, yet the authorities never enforced that rule strictly, and Bibles could easily be found online as well as in Christian bookstores.

In the first week of April, though, a government official inspected a Beijing Christian bookstore and informed the owner that books with foreign ISBN numbers could no longer be sold, according to Hong Kong’s Inkstone news website. Many Christian books are translated into Chinese in Hong Kong and Taiwan and sold in Christian bookstores in mainland China. Some Chinese Christians speculate that the government may target Bible apps next, which would make the Biblical text even more difficult to obtain.

As news of the Bible sales ban emerged, China’s government released a white paper claiming the Chinese Communist Party exercises authority over religion in order to keep “Western” religions like Christianity from being “controlled and utilized by colonialists and imperialists.” It also claimed that 200 million people in China practice religion, with 38 million Protestants. (Church leaders believe the actual number of Christians to be much greater, since many worship in unregistered house churches.)

President Xi Jinping insists on the “Sinicization of Christianity,” an effort to transform Christianity into a belief system that “aligns with the core values of socialism and so-called Chinese characteristics,” according to U.S.-based ChinaAid.

In a recent web post on that subject, Chengdu pastor Wang Yi argued that Buddhism (originating in India) was able to transform from a foreign religion to a “Chinese” religion by mixing with traditional Confucianism and Taoism. In order for Christianity to become “Chinese,” it too would have to mix with traditional religions, contradicting the exclusivity of the gospel.

Drawing from the Biblical book of Acts, Wang noted that the early church faced both outward threats from Rome and the inward threat of mixing Christianity with Jewish culture, such as by requiring circumcision for Gentile believers. “This is why Paul continually urged that Christ’s death and resurrection was the sole foundation of the church,” Wang wrote. Throughout history, believers have had to take care not to mix Christianity with local cultural beliefs.

The Communist government’s urge to mix Christianity with Chinese culture is a threat to the church, Wang concluded: “Only when the gospel dies to and is resurrected from the bondage and limitations of culture can Christianity truly be established in that culture.”


  • Brendan Bossard's picture
    Brendan Bossard
    Posted: Sun, 04/15/2018 07:46 pm

    Something to consider:  with what of my culture do I mix Christianity?

  • Rudy49
    Posted: Mon, 04/16/2018 01:11 am

    Exactly what I was thinking.

  • Bob C
    Posted: Mon, 04/16/2018 10:35 am

    I always have to laugh when they call Christianity a “Western” religion.  The Bible clearly shows Christianity or Christ came out of the Middle East not the West.  Since believers are adopted into the family of God, and God is everywhere, there is no regionalism to the Faith.  But all that has nothing to do with the Communist, who feel threatened by anything they perceive to come out of the “West” except dollars.  Then, of course, the Communist Chinese would change their tune if the USA stopped importing all their exports.     

  • follower
    Posted: Wed, 06/27/2018 12:24 pm

    Brendan, you are right, but I am afraid the point here is that the Communist government is dictating what Christianity is. 

    This is the natural problem of any government who wants more power.  Look at the recent Canadian Supreme Court decision on Trinity Western University and our Supreme Courts battles in the National Institute of Family and Life Advocates vs. Becerra and Masterpiece cake. My own state attorney general Josh Shapiro wrote me a letter lecturing me that taking religious freedom away from business owners was a small price to pay in order to encourage abortion.  For a historical perspective, look at Nebuchadnezzar and Daniel. 

    We are not in the position of the Christians in China where prison terms are the possible result of faith, but we are facing the position that our jobs may be taken away if we oppose the LBGTQ agenda, for example, Russell Berger.  

    We need to be dependent on God in the midst of these troubling times and be thankful for when God acts.  My devotion must be to God alone and not my culture.