Relations Reporting on marriage, family, and sexuality

Suffer not the children

Family | New research shows increased risks of same-sex parenting
by Kiley Crossland
Posted 12/15/17, 02:51 pm

Contrary to the narrative pushed by academia and the mainstream media, there is increasing evidence that same-sex parenting has negative effects on children.

An article published last month by Catholic University of America sociology professor Paul Sullins found children with same-sex parents suffer emotional problems two to three times as often as children raised by opposite-sex parents.

Sullins’ latest article joins other research, most notably published by himself and University of Texas professor Mark Regnerus, showing children raised by same-sex parents have increased risks of certain harms, including emotional problems, depression, and sexual abuse. Despite this, the American Psychological Association has dogmatically endorsed a “no difference” theory—namely, that there is no difference between children raised by same-sex parents and opposite-sex parents—since 2004.

The article, published in the December issue of the journal Demography, critiqued an October 2016 article in the same journal titled “Family Structure and Child Health: Does the Sex Composition of Parents Matter?” Based on data from the National Health Interview Survey, which is administered by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and collected by the U.S. Census Bureau, that study concluded there were no major differences between children raised by same-sex and opposite-sex parents.

Sullins’ rebuttal pointed to data errors the CDC had previously acknowledged and documented regarding the designation of same-sex and opposite-sex partners. In short, the data collection method used from 2004 to 2007 created confusion for respondents so that up to 40 percent of couples designated as same-sex were opposite-sex. The errors flattened the data so the authors of the 2016 study found no variance between the sample sets.

As a part of his critique, Sullins reran the study without the compromised years and found that, far from a “no difference” result, outcomes for children with same-sex parents were significantly worse. Looking at 1.5 million cases from 2008 to 2016, Sullins found the percentage of parents reporting serious emotional problems in their children jumped from 4.6 percent for children of married, opposite-sex parents to 17.6 percent for children of married, same-sex parents.

Even more importantly, Sullins told me, the authors of the original study also published an article alongside his and acknowledged the corrected data do show disadvantages for children raised by same-sex couples. Although the authors suggested there were other explanations for the difference—rates of adoption, minority stress—Sullins said it was the first time “mainstream” social scientists acknowledged the truth of the evidence showing less positive outcomes for children with same-sex parents.

Sullins believes that well-conducted studies will continue to show harms and that people will be forced to grapple with the data and come to a recognition of the truth: Namely, that God designed children for relationship with their married biological mother and father.

But he doesn’t think that will happen anytime soon.

In the meantime, in the spirit of Augustine, who taught that all truth is God’s truth, Sullins had Demography publish his dataset along with his latest article so that others can examine his data and conclusions for themselves.

“I invite anybody to take a look at any of the evidence we have about children with same-sex parents,” Sullins said. “Living with two men or two women is harmful for children. The experience of complementary parenting is important for their development into full human personhood.”

Instagram Instagram An Instagram post in which Barbie announced support for LGBT relationships

Barbie for gay marriage

The recent push by toymaker Mattel for a more inclusive Barbie doll has gone beyond body types.

In late November, the company revealed Barbie supports LGBT relationships. The post on the official BarbieStyle Instagram account shows Barbie with the fashion blogger Aimee Song–inspired doll, both wearing “Love Wins” shirts. The shirts are part of Song’s fashion line for Gay Pride month, and proceeds benefit an LGBT advocacy organization. “Such an inspiring initiative,” Barbie said in her post, “and fabulous few days I have spent with Aimee, she’s a doll!”

The post garnered more than 45,000 likes.

Song reposted the photo, saying the pair supports equal rights because #LOVEWINS, “or as some of you have speculated, maybe we’re secretly dating.”

The internet is now alive with commentators guessing whether Barbie—a toy supposedly suitable for little girls ages 3 and older—is lesbian, bisexual, or just an LGBT advocate, and how her longtime boyfriend Ken feels about the development.

Barbie may be a diva on Instagram, but the doll’s new activism will likely strain an already-tenuous relationship with Christian parents worried about the oversexualization of little girls. —K.C.

IMDB IMDB A promotional photo for Transgender Kids: Who Knows Best?

Transgender indoctrination

The Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC) this week pulled a scheduled documentary that questioned the mainstream treatment recommended for children with gender dysphoria. The film, Transgender Kids: Who Knows Best? was scheduled to be aired Tuesday night.

But due to an outcry from transgender activists, the CBC on Tuesday said, “In light of our own further review of the doc, coupled with the audience reaction we’re seeing today, we have decided not to air Transgender Kids: Who Knows Best?

Chuck Thompson, head of public affairs at CBC English Services, told the Canadian press. “We think that there are other docs that better offer insight into the realities of the transgender community, and we look forward to airing those in the future.”

Critics say the decision is part of a movement by transgender advocates to silence anyone pushing back on “gender affirming” care for children—the theory that parents and medical professionals should fully embrace a child’s self-determined gender, including name changes, hormone therapy, and eventually sex change surgery. A growing chorus of doctors is calling such treatment experimental at best and child abuse at worst. —K.C.

Kiley Crossland

Kiley is a WORLD Digital assistant editor and reports on marriage, family, and sexuality.

Read More from this Writer

Comments

  • JerryM
    Posted: Thu, 12/21/2017 05:01 pm

    I pray we have not "moved on", as the LGBT lobby would want.  Despite efforts to discredit him, Sullin's work is significant, telling the real story of our latest social engineering program.  As a civilised nation that cares for the youngest and most vulnerable we should HEED these (and other similar) findings coming from the strongest basis.  While the delusion we are under appears so strong, "but God".  What will YOU do...

ADVERTISEMENT

Social Trending