Vitals Reporting on the pro-life movement

Scales of justice weighted against pro-lifers

Abortion | Lawyers for David Daleiden say they have plenty of grounds to appeal a verdict against him
by Mary Jackson
Posted 11/18/19, 04:24 pm

Lawyers say that obvious pro-abortion bias by the federal judge who oversaw the civil trial for David Daleiden and his colleagues gives them plenty of grounds for appeal. On Friday, a federal jury ruled that Daleiden, Sandra Merritt, and others associated with the Center for Medical Progress (CMP) must pay up to $2.3 million in damages to Planned Parenthood for secretly recording the abortion giant’s associates talking about harvesting and selling aborted baby parts.

Led by Daleiden, CMP conducted a 30-month investigation using hidden cameras that exposed atrocities against unborn babies, including pricing body parts and altering abortion procedures to get the best possible specimens for research. The videos sparked several congressional investigations and fueled federal and state efforts to deprive Planned Parenthood of taxpayer dollars and curb the fetal tissue trafficking market.

After a six-week civil trial in San Francisco, U.S. District Judge William Orrick, who has known ties to Planned Parenthood, ordered jurors to pronounce Daleiden and his associates liable for trespassing, fraud, clandestine recording, and racketeering, along with breaking confidentiality agreements. The jury only had to decide the amount of damages, which came to $470,000 in actual damages—which could be tripled under federal law—and $870,000 in punitive damages.

CMP claimed throughout the trial that Daleiden and his colleagues had performed allowable investigative journalism. Afterward, the group characterized the verdict as “rigged.” From the onset of the civil trial, Orrick precluded defense witnesses, cut off lines of questioning, and prevented jurors from seeing most of CMP’s videos. He also ruled against jurors considering the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and its freedom of speech protections as a defense.

Daleiden’s lawyer, Thomas Brejcha, president and chief counsel at the Thomas More Society, said those factors give the defense a strong case before the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals and at the U.S. Supreme Court, if needed: “What David and his team did was find a way to discover and publish the truth. … This ruling is a blow to any concept of undercover journalism.”

During the trial, Daleiden testified that an ABC News 20/20 report on fetal tissue trafficking, with footage from an undercover producer posing as a potential investor and interviewing an abortionist, inspired his investigation.

“This is a dangerous precedent for citizen journalism and First Amendment civil rights across the country, sending a message that speaking truth and facts criticizing the powerful is no longer protected by our institutions,” Daleiden said.

The verdict drew a swift rebuke from pro-life advocates. Susan B. Anthony List President Marjorie Dannenfelser called it “profoundly unjust,” and Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, labeled it “outrageous.”

“The level of protections [Planned Parenthood] receives from any accountability, any oversight, any consequences for illegal behavior is stunning,” John Stonestreet, president of the Colson Center for Christian Worldview, tweeted.

Daleiden’s lawyers pointed out that Planned Parenthood has never sued him, CMP, or other parties for defaming them with false statements. Planned Parenthood’s witnesses admitted in court that the videos were accurate despite telling the media they were heavily edited.

Also on Friday, a panel of 9th Circuit judges refused to change Orrick’s 2016 order blocking any further publication of videos by CMP. The panel cited the National Abortion Federation’s report of violence and disruption stemming from the videos and the ongoing criminal proceedings against the defendants.

In a separate criminal case, Daleiden and Merritt are set to go on trial on Dec. 6 in a court in San Francisco on 14 counts each of invasion of privacy. They have pleaded not guilty on the grounds that they are undercover journalists protected from prosecution.

iStock.com/AlexRaths iStock.com/AlexRaths

Inviting death

Despite Ohio’s 45 percent increase in suicide deaths since 2007, the state’s largest nurses association still decided to endorse legalizing “medical aid in dying.”

The Ohio Nurses Association (ONA), a union with 11,000 members, became the first medical organization in the state to support assisted suicide after a meeting last month at which it approved sweeping new language calling for legislation and increased education for nurses who help terminally ill patients. “These recommendations are an extension of what nurses are ethically obligated to do, which is to protect and advocate for the rights, needs, and wants of their patients,” ONA president Deborah Arms said.

Oregon was the first state to legalize assisted suicide in 1997. Eight states and the District of Columbia have since enacted laws permitting it.

Wesley Smith, a senior fellow at the Discovery Institute’s Center for Human Exceptionalism, condemned the ONA, writing for National Review that the group’s new stance gives “moral imprimatur to doctors helping people kill themselves” and makes suicide prevention much more difficult, since nurses are telling people it is a “proper response to suffering.” —M.J.

iStock.com/Tatiana Dyuvbanova iStock.com/Tatiana Dyuvbanova

National effort

Republicans in the U.S. House and Senate last month introduced first-of-their-kind bills that would protect unborn children diagnosed with Down syndrome. The Down Syndrome Discrimination by Abortion Prohibition Act imposes a fine and imprisonment of up to five years for abortionists who kill an unborn baby because he or she has the chromosomal abnormality. The bill includes privacy protections for pregnant mothers, forbidding coercion and safeguarding them from prosecution.

In the last several years, a few states have attempted to enact similar legislation, with laws taking effect in Kentucky, Louisiana, and North Dakota. Other measures passed in Ohio and Indiana are tied up in the courts. More than two-thirds of unborn babies diagnosed with Down syndrome are aborted in the United States. —M.J.

Associated Press/Photo by David Eggert Associated Press/Photo by David Eggert Rep. Kristy Pagan with Gov. Gretchen Whitmer (right) announcing legislation to remove protections for unborn babies on Oct. 29 in Lansing, Mich.

Pro-abortion posturing

Looking ahead to the 2020 elections, Michigan Democrats, including Gov. Gretchen Whitmer, proposed legislation last month to strip the state of any protections for unborn babies, including parental consent for abortions, a 24-hour waiting period, and access to the abortion pill through telemedicine. The bills are largely symbolic since pro-life Republicans currently control the Michigan legislature.

Senate Majority Leader Mike Shirkey reacted to Whitmer’s proposed legislation by comparing abortion to the “scourge that we endured when we still had slavery in this country” in comments on Hillsdale College’s radio station last week.

Meanwhile, pro-life groups in the state are leading a petition drive for two veto-proof ballot initiatives, including one banning dismemberment abortion unless it would save the mother’s life. —M.J.

Mary Jackson

Mary is a graduate of the World Journalism Institute mid-career course and lives in the San Francisco Bay Area with her husband and four children. Follow Mary on Twitter @mbjackson77

Read more from this writer

Comments

You must be a WORLD Member and be logged in to the website to comment.
  • OldMike
    Posted: Mon, 11/18/2019 09:41 pm

    It would be easy to just roll over and quit fighting against the culture of death that’s attempting to take over.  Easy, and wrong. 

    It’s encouraging to see the efforts of those on the front lines. 

  • Big Jim
    Posted: Tue, 11/19/2019 02:53 pm

    Is it just me or does it seem like conservatives/Republicans usually get punished and Leftists/Democrats end up skating?

  • OldMike
    Posted: Tue, 11/19/2019 04:11 pm

    Yessir, does seem that way. But it’s far from over. 

  • news2me
    Posted: Tue, 11/19/2019 11:02 pm

    Wow, what a name, Kristy PAGAN. Just saying...

ADVERTISEMENT