Muse Reporting on the arts and culture

NFL shifts stance on kneeling, again

Media | The league isn’t the only one toning down criticism of sideline protests
by Sharon Dierberger
Posted 6/09/20, 05:23 pm

In the four years since Colin Kaepernick, then a quarterback for the NFL’s San Francisco 49ers, first took a knee on the sidelines during the playing of “The Star-Spangled Banner,” the league has bobbled its response like a receiver trying not to drop a pass. First, it did not condone players kneeling to protest police brutality. Then it mandated they stand during the national anthem or stay out of sight. Then NFL leaders took some more time to think about it. And finally, last week, following nationwide protests following the death of George Floyd, they encouraged sideline demonstrations.

“We … admit we were wrong for not listening to NFL players earlier and encourage all to speak out and peacefully protest,” NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell said in a video message on Friday. His statement raised the question, listening to which players?

Earlier in the week, New Orleans Saints quarterback Drew Brees spoke out against the sideline protests. In an interview with Yahoo Finance, he said as the grandson of World War II veterans, he “will never agree with anybody” doing something he considers disrespectful to the U.S. flag. Brees added that he stood during the anthem with his hand over his heart as a sign of unity in the face of social problems.

Fellow NFL players and others quickly berated Brees, and on Friday he apologized in an Instagram post.

“It breaks my heart to know the pain I have caused,” Brees wrote. “I condemn the years of oppression that have taken place throughout our black communities and still exist today.”

The outspoken Christian asked for forgiveness from anyone he had offended, saying he had not done enough to understand the struggles of African Americans.

President Donald Trump reacted to Brees’ statement in a series of tweets. After saying he was a big fan, the president admonished him for withdrawing his original stance on honoring the flag, adding, “There are other things you can protest, but not our Great American Flag—NO KNEELING!”

Six hours after Trump’s tweet, Brees was back on Instagram with a message to the president. He said the flag is not the issue but a distraction from addressing “racial injustice, economic oppression, police brutality, and judicial and prison reform.”

On Saturday night, Goodell called the president’s comments divisive.

Brees’ wife, Brittany, apologized on Saturday on the Brees Dream Foundation Instagram account, saying, “WE ARE THE PROBLEM.” She added that she suddenly realized her views on disrespecting the flag meant she didn’t understand what African Americans are fighting for.

Last week, Grant Napear, the play-by-play announcer for the NBA’s Sacramento Kings, resigned after being criticized for tweeting, “ALL LIVES MATTER … EVERY SINGLE ONE!!!” Sacramento’s KHTK-AM also fired him from his radio hosting gig.

Napear apologized and said he did not realize that saying “all lives matter” ran counter to the message of the Black Lives Matter movement. Although he won’t say whether he plans to sue to get either of his jobs back, someone started a GoFundMe campaign to raise $100,000 for his legal fees. The campaign had raised about $11,200 by Tuesday.

After Brees’ original comments, former NFL head coach Tony Dungy, another outspoken Christian from the ranks of professional football, commented that his dad, a veteran, would not have considered NFL players’ protests as disrespectful to the flag. But Dungy, who is African American, also indicated everyone should have the freedom to express opinions: “We can’t be afraid to say, ‘OK, I don’t agree with you but let’s talk about this.’ … We can’t just say anytime something happens we don’t agree with ‘Hey, I’m done with that and this person.’ That doesn’t make sense.”

Associated Press/Photo by Dominic Lipinski/PA (file) Associated Press/Photo by Dominic Lipinski/PA (file) Christo at the unveiling his art installation in The Serpentine lake in London’s Hyde Park

The death of an eclectic activist-artist

Christo Vladimirov Javacheff, fabric and environmental artist, died on May 31 at age 84.

Born in 1933 in Bulgaria, he watched his country swing from royal dictatorship to Axis ally to Soviet state by the time he was 11. His father ran a fabric factory and his mother worked at a school of fine arts, which Christo would later attend. His early art involved wrapping mundane objects in fabric or paper. Later, he’d drape entire buildings.

When the Hungarian Revolution of 1956 upended the region, Christo fled the country by bribing a railway official and stowing aboard a train carrying medical supplies. He eventually landed in Paris.

While painting a portrait in 1958, he met his future wife, Jeanne-Claude de Guillebon. The two married in 1962, and Jeanne-Claude became an artist out of love for Christo. “If he had been a dentist, I would have become a dentist,” she once told art critic Calvin Tomkins. They moved to New York in 1964 and collaborated until Jeanne-Claude’s death in 2009.

The couple’s first major politically charged work was Wall of Oil in 1962. They stacked 89 oil barrels across the Rue Visconti in Paris, obstructing traffic and depicting frustration with the Berlin Wall. Assembled without permission, the work stood for eight hours.

From there, Christo tackled larger projects: hanging a bright orange curtain across a mountain valley in Colorado, surrounding islands in Florida with princess-pink fabric, shrouding Berlin’s Reichstag building in silver cloth, and sending 7,503 orange gates marching through Central Park.

In 2018, Christo returned to his roots: barrels. He stacked 7,506 red, blue, and mauve barrels in a trapezoidal shape as tall as Egypt’s Sphinx and set them floating in The Serpentine in London’s Hyde Park for nearly 100 days. The rippling lake reflected the barrels, creating an image the artist called an abstract painting.

Like abstract art, Christo said, the interpretation was up to the viewer: “Any interpretation is legitimate, critical or positive. … All [interpretations] make you think. This is why we’re human; to think.” —Anna Johansen

Associated Press/Photo by Mark J. Terrill (file) Associated Press/Photo by Mark J. Terrill (file) Kanye West

Giving families a boost

As protests against police brutality shook the country in recent weeks, many celebrities donated to funds for bail money for arrested protesters. Rapper Kanye West, declared America’s highest-paid musician last week by Forbes, personally attended a protest in Chicago last week and donated $2 million to the families of Ahmaud Arbery, Breonna Taylor, and George Floyd. He created a college savings fund for the 6-year-old daughter of Floyd, who died on May 25 after a police officer in Minneapolis knelt on his neck during an attempted arrest. West also pledged to help pay legal expenses for the families of Arbery, who was pursued, shot, and killed by a father and son in February in Georgia, and Taylor, whom police shot dead in April while serving a search warrant at her Louisville, Ky., home. African American business owners in Chicago who lost property during riots also have benefitted from West’s generosity.

West’s career as one of the kings of hip-hop pivoted dramatically in 2019. He released a gospel-themed album titled Jesus Is King and began talking about his new faith in Christ, which he claimed made him a better husband, father, and person.

“I’m definitely born again,” he said in an interview with GQ. “Christ altered my ego.” —Collin Garbarino

Associated Press (file) Associated Press (file) From left: Ruth, Anita, Bonnie, and June Pointer perform in Phoenix in 1973.

Remembering the voice of the Pointer Sisters

Grammy-winner Bonnie Pointer died on Monday of cardiac arrest, publicist Roger Neal said. She was 69. Pointer convinced her three sisters—Ruth, Anita, and June—to form a group in 1969 that borrowed elements from funk, soul, pop, and more. The Pointer Sisters’ early hits included “Yes We Can Can” and “Fairytale.” Bonnie often filled the role of lead singer before she left the group for a moderately successful solo career in 1977, signing with Motown Records. She had a hit in 1979 with a disco cover of The Elgins’ 1966 Motown hit “Heaven Must Have Sent You.”

“The Pointer Sisters would never have happened had it not been for Bonnie,” her sister Anita said.

The youngest of the Pointer sisters, June, died in 2006. Ruth and Anita survive, along with two older brothers, Aaron and Fritz. —Rachel Lynn Aldrich

Sharon Dierberger
Read more from this writer

Comments

You must be a WORLD Member and logged in to the website to comment.
  • AlanE
    Posted: Tue, 06/09/2020 06:05 pm

    Kanye West may well be born again, but the ever-growing trend of doing acts of righteousness for public display needs to come under the review of Jesus' words in Matthew 6:1-4. 

  • heathercoulter
    Posted: Wed, 06/10/2020 04:44 pm

    I don't understand why you would criticize West for his generosity.   Let's rejoice that he is professing Christ and doing good works.   Just because the news reporters want to tell us about it doesn't mean he has been seeking that notoriety.  

  • Kris
    Posted: Tue, 06/09/2020 06:29 pm

    Bye-bye, NFL.  Instead of evaluating talent, strategy, and teams, all the commentary and pre-game coverage will focus on who kneels, who doesn't, who's wearing what symbol, etc.  The national anthem didn't used to be even televised except at the Super Bowl, but with protesters, it became a big focus.  It will tear teams apart and alienate fans.  I think it trivializes an important heart and justice issue:  Am I loving my neighbor as Christ would, or not?

  • Ann Marshall
    Posted: Wed, 06/10/2020 08:49 am

    The peaceful protest of kneeling should have been tactfully acknowledged as a form of free speech. It's not something I would do as a protest: to me, the visual is all wrong since looks like one is doing an obeisance to the flag. But no one was harmed, there was no need for all the furor. 

  • RC
    Posted: Wed, 06/10/2020 09:30 am

    I don’t see it as an argument about free speech. When you are on the clock, on the job, you abide by the rules of your employer unless they are asking you to compromise your morals or ethics.  What you do on your own time is not your employer’s business, unless your are doing something that would reflect badly on your employer.

  • Allen Johnson
    Posted: Wed, 06/10/2020 12:36 pm

    Read Daniel 2 again, about the three Hebrew lads tossed into a fiery furnace because they did not kneel to the nation's "flag."
    Or read again the first two commandments of the Ten Commandments.
    Or remember that many of the early Christian martyrs were torched or fed to the lions because they did not do the simple act of pinching a piece of incense to Caesar.
    Finally, consider the numerous churches that have an American Flag and a so-called Christian Flag  on flag poles or at the front of the altar or podium. Guess which flag gets to be in the positiion of honor? Now explain why that is not idolatry?

  • Ann Marshall
    Posted: Fri, 06/12/2020 09:46 am

    A civil (in the sense of civilized, consonant with "good manners") form of protest was censured. Due in part to that censure, we are where we are. The NFL is strongly supported by public monies. No one should be  required to shed their free speech rights in order to play football. 

  • MG
    Posted: Fri, 06/19/2020 09:39 pm

    No one was stopping anyone's "free speech".  When you are on your employer's clock, you forfeit the right to just say anything you want and do just anything you want to do.  

  • Ann Marshall
    Posted: Sun, 06/28/2020 03:57 pm

    I gather you were offended by the kneeling. Freedom of speech means sometimes you have to civilly endure being offended in the public square. 

ADVERTISEMENT