Compassion Reporting on poverty fighting and criminal justice

Changing policing for good

Compassion | The movement for law enforcement reforms gains momentum
by Charissa Koh
Posted 6/24/20, 02:56 pm

An article written by retired officer Randy Petersen about police reform two years ago saw a spike in views recently when he posted it on his LinkedIn page.

“More people [were] interested in that in the last six weeks than probably in the last two years combined,” said Petersen, who now works for Texas Public Policy Foundation researching law enforcement and criminal justice issues.

He also recently received calls from two state lawmakers—unusual, since the Texas Legislature is not in session—to discuss police training, hiring, unions, and police use of military equipment. On June 15, he spoke at a TPPF livestreamed event about police reform and had “double the highest amount of live viewers.”

Since George Floyd’s May 25 death in Minneapolis, public policy advocates say they have seen a spike in support for police reform. A nationwide survey conducted June 11-15 by AP-NORC indicated almost 70 percent of Americans want to see a “complete overhaul” or “major changes” to the criminal justice system.

Heather Rice-Minus, vice president of government affairs at Prison Fellowship, said Democratic and Republican lawmakers and Trump administration staff have contacted the organization since Floyd’s death. Sen. Mike Braun, R-Ind., asked to discuss a proposal to reform qualified immunity for police. Sen. Tim Scott, R-S.C., asked for the group’s support for the police reform bill he introduced in the last week.

Prison Fellowship has not yet endorsed the Senate bill or a House police reform measure introduced by Democrats, but Rice-Minus said the group wants to see lawmakers address several issues: officer de-escalation training, community policing models, qualified immunity reform, and the transfer of military equipment to police. She said the energy around those topics could lead to substantial policy changes. “There’s something happening in this country right now that I’ve not seen in all my years of working on these issues,” she said.

She also hopes the momentum will carry beyond policing to criminal justice reforms. Prison Fellowship is pushing for proportionate sentencing, bail reform, and access to good legal counsel for those on trial.

On June 16, President Donald Trump signed an executive order calling for greater police transparency, more de-escalation training, and a program for social workers to help police interact with crime victims, people experiencing homelessness, and the mentally ill. John Malcolm, director of the Heritage Foundation’s Center for Legal and Judicial Studies, called the measures a step in the right direction. He noted more journalists have requested interviews with him lately and said the momentum for reform could produce results in areas where the Senate and House bills agree—officer training and better use-of-force policy. “I think that there is a recognition that some police reform is very much called for, and I think it’s going to happen,” he said.

But a spike in interest doesn’t always equal good legislation.

Petersen, the retired officer in Texas, said the president’s executive order already covers most of the law enforcement policy areas the federal government can influence. The most effective reforms will come as local departments change hiring and training practices and learn their communities’ priorities and expectations.

“That’s not as exciting as saying, ‘Let’s just defund the police,’” Petersen said. “No one wants to protest saying, ‘Hey, in 30 years, we’d like to have different policing.’”

Reforming the laws police enforce will also more quickly change how the police operate, he said. Petersen pointed out that Eric Garner died in 2014 after resisting New York City police officers who attempted to arrest him for selling loose cigarettes. Less burdensome laws—especially for less serious offenses—would decrease chances of violent police interactions, Petersen said.

High-profile pushes like the Minneapolis City Council’s resolution to transform its police department and New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio’s vow to cut police funding have snatched headlines. But the AP-NORC poll found most Americans oppose defunding police departments. Rafael Mangual, a legal policy expert at the Manhattan Institute, warned funding cuts that reduce police presence in vulnerable neighborhoods would lead to more crime: “I think a lot of people who are supporting these protests are doing so from a perch that does not allow them to see or understand life in a truly dangerous neighborhood.”

Associated Press/Photo by Evan Vucci (file) Associated Press/Photo by Evan Vucci (file) President Donald Trump

New immigration rules announced

The Trump administration said this week it was further restricting immigration to preserve jobs for U.S. workers. On Monday, President Donald Trump announced extensions to earlier limits on immigrant visas. Back in April, the administration suspended the issuance of green cards to those outside the United States for 60 days. Trump pushed the timeframe of the restriction to the end of the year. Officials will reevaluate and possibly renew the restrictions at that time.

The United States is also placing a hold on issuing certain nonimmigrant visas to people living outside of the country.

“Under ordinary circumstances, properly administered temporary worker programs can provide benefits to the economy,” he said, but under the circumstances, foreign workers “pose an unusual threat to the employment of American workers.”

The hold applies to H-1B, H-2B, J, and L visas. That list includes visas for specialty workers—often employed in the tech field—nonagricultural workers like landscapers, work and school exchange programs, and in-company transfers to the United States. The rules make exceptions for certain healthcare workers who would fight COVID-19, as well as those coming to work in the strapped U.S. food supply chain.

Asylum regulations are also getting stricter. The federal government published a rule on Monday saying U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services will no longer have to abide by a 30-day deadline to process work authorization requests from people seeking asylum, beginning in late August. Citing a spike in claims, USCIS described the deadline as burdensome and said removing the time limit would allow officials more flexibility to vet entrants. A separate rule, set for publication on Friday, tightens requirements for asylum seekers to get work permits. —Rachel Lynn Aldrich

Associated Press/Photo by Rich Pedroncelli (file) Associated Press/Photo by Rich Pedroncelli (file) California Gov. Gavin Newsom

Extending care

California officials are considering changes to the state foster care system to help vulnerable youth who become adults during the coronavirus pandemic. A bill introduced in the state Senate would allow more foster youth to stay in care until they turned 21. If passed, the law would also keep many who turn 21 this year in state custody through June of next year. Gov. Gavin Newsom already signed an executive order to relax or suspend some foster care regulations. It allowed foster youth who were scheduled to “age out” at 21 to stay under state care until the end of this month.

“If at least their minimum needs can be covered, maybe they can keep a leg up in higher education, maybe they can hold on until the economy returns,” Amy Lemley, executive director of the San Francisco–based John Burton Advocates for Youth, told The Mercury News. —R.L.A.

Staving off poverty

Several economists believe stimulus checks sent out by the federal government kept many people from sliding into poverty during the coronavirus pandemic.

In research they plan to present on Thursday, James Sullivan of the University of Notre Dame and Bruce Meyer and Jeehoon Han of the University of Chicago found the estimated U.S. monthly poverty rate fell 2.3 percentage points between January and May despite the pandemic-related shutdowns and subsequent job losses. The researchers said the stimulus checks everyone received in April and May explained the decline.

After nationwide shutdowns hammered the economy early this year, incremental reopening plans have already brought good news. U.S. employers defied economists’ expectations by adding 2.5 million jobs in May, accompanied by a 13.3 percent decline in the unemployment rate. —R.L.A.

Read more Compassion Sign up for the Compassion email
Charissa Koh

Charissa is a WORLD reporter who often writes about poverty fighting and prison reform, including profiling ministries in the annual Hope Awards for Effective Compassion competition. She is also a part of WORLD's investigative unit, the Caleb Team. Charissa resides with her husband, Josh, in Austin, Texas. Follow her on Twitter @CharissaKoh.

Read more from this writer


You must be a WORLD Member and logged in to the website to comment.
  • Narissara
    Posted: Wed, 06/24/2020 03:30 pm

    Who are these "vulnerable youth" in California?  Why are they in foster care past the age of majority, at which time they gain the right to vote, enter into contracts, join the military, etc.?  I must be missing something -- usually only individuals determined by a court to be mentally incompetent remain wards of the state past the age of 18, and yet a supporter of this bill makes reference to opportunities for higher education.  

  • Laura W
    Posted: Wed, 06/24/2020 05:10 pm

    I don't know the details in this case, but I would expect that it's some sort of optional support. After all, how many 18-year-olds are really ready to take on the world without a family behind them?

  • Katie
    Posted: Thu, 06/25/2020 10:57 am

    As a foster parent, I believe I can speak to this issue by giving an example. Let's say there is a 14-year-old girl who has lived with abusive and/or neglectful parents her whole life. Suddenly, she's removed from the situation because someone finally called CPS, and she finds herself in foster care. She has great survival skills but poor emotional development, poor social skills, and doesn't do well in school. She's been traumatized by years of abuse and/or neglect and is now living with strangers. Statistics tell us she will change foster homes at least two or three times before she turns 18. If she were to "age out" at that point, she would be totally on her own with no support, because by now her family (such as it was) is either totally out of the picture or more dangerous to her than living on the streets. This girl is a "vulnerable youth." She has no one to turn to for help with decision making and is at a four times higher risk than a non-foster youth of being trafficked. Kids like this are the reason states are extending the "age out" age to 21 and offering additional support. And this might be an "example," but it's based on kids I have personally known. There are many kids facing this kind of situation. Also, the reference to higher education is because many of these kids do want to go to college and make something of themselves, but they have a lot to overcome and may need extra support to make the transition.

    I realize many people don't understand what it's like for foster kids or just how much they have to overcome in order to break the cycle. I hope this helps. For an inspiring true story of a kid who faced these kinds of hardships and rose above I highly recommend Walk to Beautiful by Jimmy Wayne.

  • Narissara
    Posted: Thu, 06/25/2020 12:32 pm

    Thank you.  I firmly believe in parental rights and have actively worked to preserve them, but I've also seen situations where the state does indeed need to get involved.  At the same time, I've seen and heard of too many situations where foster families are at least partly motivated because of the supplemental income it provides.  

    I guess my concern here then would be that the families providng support to these youths receive thorough training in how to adequately equip them for transition into adulthood by the time they reach the age of 21.  Otherwise, they're just postponing the inevitable, or setting them up for a lifetime of dependence on the state.  If individuals must look to the state for financial support, all too often the state starts thinking it can tell them how to live.  That's exactly the endgame of socialism.  And we are talking about California, whose elected leaders at both the state and federal level have been at the forefront of the shift toward socialism.

  • Katie
    Posted: Thu, 06/25/2020 07:43 pm

    I agree Narissara, I don't want to see everyone just "postponing the inevitable" either. Training and life-skill support needs to be part of the equation. And I do realize some foster parents are in it for the wrong reasons. But in my experience, there are vulnerable youth who truly do need more help with their transitions into adulthood. It's an area of need I would love to see Christians step into more.

  • Janet B
    Posted: Thu, 06/25/2020 01:05 pm

    Tim Scott's bill in the Senate did not pass.  Here is his take on it...