Skip to main content

Parsing privilege

Beyond one-dimensional analysis

Parsing privilege

Marcuse lectures at an event in 1967. (Jung/ullstein bild via Getty Images)

This fall brings the 50th anniversary of a guest lecture I attended while in college. The speaker was Herbert Marcuse, known in 1969 as chief theorist for the Marxist new left. Marcuse’s most famous book, One-Dimensional Man, argued that capitalism exploits people and nature and turns art and culture into commodities. I applauded, not knowing then the universality of sin and the historical fact that socialism is even more prone to lead to dictatorship and war.

Marcuse’s analysis was one-dimensional, as is one outgrowth of Marxist analysis, the “privilege walk” exercise now standard at many U.S. colleges, including Christian ones. Amy Julia Becker, author of White Picket Fences (NavPress, 2018), describes what she went through at Princeton along with 60 other students. “If your ancestors came to the United States by force, take one step back. … If your parents or guardians attended college take one step forward.” 

If you know Becker is white, you can guess the rest of the story: “With every step forward, I feel my heart thump a little harder. … All of us who advance to the front of the room have white skin.” Becker is right to report that some structural injustice based on race is real. I’ve witnessed white police differently treating groups of white and black teens. So it’s important to understand the importance of privilege—but the privilege issue is complicated. 

I’ll pick on White Picket Fences not because it’s a bad book—to the contrary, it’s well-written and well-intentioned—but because Becker at first accepts today’s one-dimensional clichés. And yet, her own story of upper-class privilege shows elements of the opposite. It came with a dad who commuted from Connecticut into Manhattan on weekdays, ran long distances on weekends, and essentially ignored her. In high school she felt his absence “in my gut” and “started involuntarily vomiting my food after every meal.” Furthermore, “the pressure I had internalized from teachers and coaches and friends overwhelmed my system so much that it simply ceased to function.” 

Eventually Becker required emergency hospitalization. Doctors never determined a physical cause, but after her hospital stay she still fainted regularly and vomited after every meal. She notes how “my peers shared my obsession with the scale.” They received good grades and gained acceptance to elite colleges, but did their “years of binging and purging and shame” show privilege or misery?

“The real privilege of my life has come in learning what it means to love others.”—Amy Julia Becker

Becker has cared for a young daughter with Down syndrome and a middle-aged mother-in-law with liver cancer. Becker was privileged to hold a trash can while her mother-in-law “vomited, draining her tubes of blood and bile after her surgery,” and to spend “the night by her side to make sure she didn’t lurch from bed.” 

Happily, Chapter 9 of Becker’s book takes a gospel turn. Without the hardships of her mother-in-law’s death and her child’s unanticipated difficulties, her future might have left her like Matthew in one of Caravaggio’s paintings, “counting the coins of my existence, unable or unwilling to look up into the light. … The real privilege of my life has come in learning what it means to love others, that love involves suffering and sacrifice and sleepless nights and tears and heartache and great gifts.”

Marcuse’s One-Dimensional Man introduced to Americans a concept now fashionable: “intersectionality,” the idea that to get a whole look at unfairness we have to add up the influence of race, class, and sex. But those still leave us in only one dimension based on externals. We should at least add on a second dimension that takes note of other factors, such as growing up with two loving parents rather than with a single mom or with parents who are cold or absent. 

Oct. 10-13 brings the eighth biennial International Herbert Marcuse Society Conference. Tenured Marxists will converge at the University of California Santa Barbara to present academic papers on topics such as “the dialectics of resistance today” and “Can violence play a role … for precipitating system change?”

Conference organizers recommend lodging on the UCSB campus at the Club & Guest House for $199 per night. Backup is a nearby hotel for $139 or $159 per night (“includes hot breakfast buffet”).

Crucial question: Will any of the participants have perceived God’s love, and thus moved into a third dimension based on the privilege of loving others because God first loved us?


You must be a WORLD Member and logged in to the website to comment.
  • TxAgEngr
    Posted: Tue, 08/27/2019 04:00 pm

    Will the International Herbert Marcuse Society Conference have a break-out session on how to create mass grave sites with bulldozers and machine guns?

  • RC
    Posted: Mon, 09/09/2019 09:04 am

    Excellent point and probably not. They are more concerned with idealism than reality.

  • Neil Evans
    Posted: Tue, 08/27/2019 06:33 pm

    The One Person in human history Who was the most privileged is best known for, and found His greatest joy in, Giving Himself to others.  At the same time it seems that the most sad people are those who seek to better themselves by taking from others.  "It's not fair" is a very distracting attitude.  It was central to the Devil's temptation to Adam and Eve: "It's not fair that God withhold something from you."  And it appealed to the pride that is the very arena of our sin nature. 

    It is interesting that the most encouraging "success" stories are those that describe a person overcoming extreme obstacles.  And yet we are prone to try to do away with the very circumstances in which victory is begun.

    James describes it this way: "For where jealousy and selfish ambition exist, there will be disorder and every vile practice.  But the wisdom from above is first pure, then peaceable, gentle, open to reason, full of mercy and good fruits, impartial and sincere.  And a harvest of righteousness is sown in peace by those who make peace." (James 3:16-18)

  •  Xion's picture
    Posted: Wed, 08/28/2019 01:31 am

    I love the third dimension of privilege, i.e. "the privilege of loving others because God first loved us".

    One word that leaped off the page was "unfairness".  Since when has everyone bought into the notion that life is supposed to be fair?  Socialism is the economics of envy.  The Bible teaches we should seek the well being of others and rejoice with them.

    Privilege has come to be a dirty word.  Anyone who has two parents or succeeds in life is stealing from the pool of limited resources.  Reading to your children or helping them to do well is deemed horrible because it gives them an unfair advantage.  Heaven forbid if they are labeled privileged.

  • Caminho
    Posted: Thu, 08/29/2019 03:01 am

    Speaking of "privelege" should indeed be nuanced; to assume someone is more or less privilged simply based on external obvious features is no different in many ways from standard racism/sexism, etc. That said, the concept of privelege is incredibly important. Too often the wealthy/successful believe that their position is the result of hard work or sacrifice, etc.; it is then easy to assume that everyone who has difficulties simply don't deserve success like they do. While it is a blessing to live in a society that resembles a meritocracy in some ways, our context growing up makes a massive difference to the likelihood of our success (not to mention a great deal of luck/providence). And it is useful to recognize that often there are privileges statistically more often associated with certain races, genders, etc.