Skip to main content

Culture Movies

A society’s secrets



A society’s secrets

Netflix film offers drama, humor, and familiar faces

The Nazi occupation of British territory during World War II might seem an unlikely setting for a feel-good, heartwarming story. But The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society (Netflix) is a delightful two-hour escape, with drama, humor, and a cast that will be familiar to many.

The movie is based on a 2008 book written by Mary Ann Shaffer after a brief visit to Guernsey, an English Channel island near the French mainland. The author was intrigued to learn about the island’s occupation from 1940 to 1945. Despite the chance to evacuate, Guernsey’s residents largely stayed put, with the exception of most of the children, who were shipped off to England. The Germans fortified the island with stout defenses, bringing in slave labor from Poland and Russia to build watchtowers along the shoreline.

The opening scene is set in London in 1946. Juliet Ashton (played by Lily James) seems to have it all. Her career as an author is beginning to take off. Life in England after the Allied victory is full of joy, and her rich, handsome American boyfriend has just proposed, with the promise of a fabulous future life together in New York City. In the midst of all this, a letter arrives from Dawsey Adams (Michiel Huisman), a pig farmer living on Guernsey.

Dawsey had found Juliet’s address in a copy of a book by Charles Lamb that was a comfort to him during the occupation. In these pre-Amazon, pre-internet days, he asks if Juliet can help him to find more books by the same author, to be shared with the members of the intriguingly named Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society.

Juliet is happy to help, and in a series of letters, learns enough about the society to tantalize her: She must visit Guernsey and find out more about how this book club came to be, and how its members used literature and the bonds of friendship to help get them through dark and difficult days. Juliet decides that this would make the perfect subject for a London Times article.

The first meeting of the literary society that Juliet attends makes clear that she will need to earn the trust of the members before she can learn more. What secrets are they hiding, and why can’t they talk about them now that the war is over? Why won’t they allow her to write about them for the newspaper? Gradually, the Society members open up to Juliet, and she learns about one of their founders, Elizabeth, an inspirational figure and an outspoken friend to the downtrodden.


Glen Powell and Lily James (Netflix)

Elizabeth was indignant at the mistreatment of prisoners of war by the Nazis and showed great courage to help those under that yoke. Yet she did not judge the occupiers as a whole: Her friendship with one young soldier blossomed into romance. Juliet wonders: Where is Elizabeth, and what will become of the daughter she left behind?

This is not the kind of movie one watches for its twists and turns: It has a fairly predictable plot. Nevertheless, the story is well-told, and the costumes and scenery of 1940s London and Guernsey are beautifully filmed. How different life was just a few generations ago is brought out again and again, in both civilized London, and even more so on the more idyllic Guernsey. Consider the words of Juliet’s landlady as she makes her way up the stairs: “No more typing now, Ms. Ashton. It’s well after 10!”

Fans of Downton Abbey will find familiar faces among the cast. Leading actress Lily James played Lady Rose MacClare on the popular series. Viewers will also see Jessica Brown Findlay (Lady Sybil), and Penelope Wilton (Isobel Crawley), along with other familiar faces and voices.

The movie will not win any Oscars and did not break any new ground in the art of moviemaking. Yet it makes for an enjoyable evening of entertainment, with a few tugs at the heartstrings. A few references to extramarital relations make it less suitable for younger viewers.


You must be a WORLD Member and logged in to the website to comment.
  • Steve Shive
    Posted: Fri, 01/11/2019 05:17 am


    All of the above PLUS it was a breath of fresh air!!

  •  Deb O's picture
    Deb O
    Posted: Fri, 01/11/2019 10:13 am

    Excellent movie! I'm so glad you reviewed it so others will find it. Please, more movies like this one.

  • Kyleigh
    Posted: Sun, 01/13/2019 11:58 pm

    I'm a little surprised at how positive this review is considering two major flaws in the movie (aside from being a dressed-up Hallmark movie).

    The first flaw is that it views romantic desire as the pinnacle of human existence - Juliet won't be fulfilled unless she's married to the right guy, and Elizabeth is noble for getting into bed while unmarried with a German because it shows her lack of bigotry. There are notes of this theme in other characters as well, like the friend Juliet rooms with.

    The second flaw is that it portrays the film's only homosexual character as a deeply mature, noble friend in contrast to the only Christian character who is portrayed as a prudish, judgmental fiend. Of course, in real life there are many homosexuals who are noble friends and many so-called Christians who are judgmental fiends. However, the point of these characters is for us to love the homosexual and hate the Christian, pushing a modern agenda into the 1940s.


  • VolunteerBB
    Posted: Mon, 01/14/2019 02:01 pm

    Thanks for writing a counter to the review.  I always carefully consider both before viewing or with whom I will view it.

  • AslanReturns
    Posted: Thu, 01/17/2019 12:45 pm

    I would agree there was a lot to like about this movie but am surprised that this review didn’t even mention the "wink" at homosexuality via one of the more influential characters of the movie nor the negative portrayal of Christianity via the vile innkeeper.  Certainly not surprised that Netflix would include these elements into their movies but it would have been nice, given WORLD Magazines commitment to your motto, that you would have made even a slight reference.