Compassion International faces eviction from India

International Aid | Time may be running out for Christian charities in the world’s largest democracy
by Evan Wilt
Posted 12/06/16, 03:21 pm

WASHINGTON—Compassion International, a Christian nongovernmental organization that aids 145,000 impoverished Indian children, has three weeks left in the country unless officials give it a reprieve.

“We’ve simply run out of funds,” Stephen Oakley, the group’s senior vice president and general counsel, told the U.S. House Foreign Affairs Committee today.

Compassion employs 6,000 workers in India who provide aid to children living in extreme poverty. It has worked in India since 1968 and is the largest humanitarian presence in the second most populated country in the world—providing $50 million in annual relief funds. But India is cracking down on foreign NGOs based on fears that groups are using humanitarian work to mask evangelization efforts. Those fears have prompted the government to block the inflow of relief dollars.

So far, Indian officials have ignored pleas from U.S. lawmakers.

“We have spent nine months and hundreds of hours dealing with the Indian bureaucracy on this, and it looks like the bureaucracy is trying to run out the clock,” House Foreign Affairs chairman Rep. Ed Royce, R-Calif., said. “This is not a hearing that the committee expected to be holding.”

Oakley said Compassion has sought legal counsel to ensure it’s in good standing with the Indian government, but a complete breakdown in communication has exacerbated the situation.

India is the world’s largest democracy, with a population of 1.25 billion. But it also suffers from extreme poverty. More than 100 million children live without access to proper nutrition or other basic needs. The government does not have well-established anti-poverty programs and relies on foreign aid groups for humanitarian relief.

Oakley said Compassion is working with other NGOs to help take over relief work in the country should it have to shut down. But he expects more than 80 percent of the 145,000 children under Compassion’s care to fall through the cracks.

India screens foreign aid groups through its Foreign Contribution Regulation Act (FCRA). In 2011, India’s Ministry of Home Affairs revised the law, leaving it up to broad interpretation.

The revised FCRA now states the government can block funds “for any activities detrimental to the national interest.”

“One of the problems with the FCRA is that the Indian government has adopted a very wide interpretation of what is anti-national,” said Irfan Nooruddin, Georgetown University’s India Initiative director. “Anything that the government doesn’t agree with is now anti-national. There is no end in sight for them.”

India is one of the most religiously diverse nations in the world. It is predominately Hindu, but also is home to more than 130 million Muslims and more than 50 million Christians. Nooruddin said this issue should be of great concern to the United States because it’s an attack on religious liberty.

Some lawmakers fear the consequences of berating the Indian government over its domestic policy.

“When I think about where we are in the U.S.-India relationship in a broad scope, it is really at a peak right now,” said Rep. Ami Bera, D-Calif., the only Indian-American member of Congress. “That’s one of my concerns with how this issue is resolved.”

Compassion meets children’s physical needs while promoting emotional and spiritual development, including the incoporation of Scripture and Christian teachings into its work. Oakley said the Indian government revoked the organization’s FCRA license because it identified several “black sheep” within Compassion who worked against “national interests.” But government officials are no longer communicating with the organization and will not clarify what that means.

Compassion isn’t alone in its situation with the Indian government. Nooruddin said 11,500 other NGOs, both secular and faith-based, have lost their FCRA licenses in the last several years.

Rep. Chris Smith, R-N.J., called the situation an affront to religious freedom and said the United States should take it seriously.

“The threat on Compassion is indicative of what is happening to NGOs around the world,” he said. “The United States has the moral duty, our government, to put a tourniquet with the greatest extent possible on this deterioration [of religious freedom].”

This article has been edited to clarify the type of work Compassion International does with children in India and the limited amount of information the Indian government has provided for revoking Compassion International’s FCRA license. 

Evan Wilt

Evan is a World Journalism Institute graduate and a former WORLD reporter.

Read more from this writer


You must be a WORLD Member and logged in to the website to comment.
  • My Two Cents
    Posted: Tue, 12/06/2016 07:28 pm

    I currently support a girl from India through Compassion International. I have supported her for about 8 years, and it breaks my heart to know that her opportunities she has now to go to college to become a nurse may soon end. Does India want all their girls to become victims of human trafficking? That's the only alternative for them if the government continues this descent. 

  • VT
    Posted: Tue, 01/03/2017 06:37 pm



  • KR
    Posted: Fri, 12/09/2016 09:13 pm

    It seems to be a platitude of world religions textbooks that Hinduism is the world's "most tolerant religion."  Unfortunately, however, Hindu tolerance seems often mostly to involve the assertion that all religions are one, since all religions are simply different ways of going up the "same mountain."  The Hindu tolerator, thus, may turn out to be an exclusivist, inisisting that they know the mountain we're all on and holding that really the only way to conceive of that mountain is in terms of pantheism. 


    But, just as much Indian tolerance turns out to involve a politely postured assertion of supremacy over outsiders, this tolerance also may fail to extend to poor members of the lower castes of India any real compassion and care.  Born into low caste poverty?  Well, since karma brought you to this, it must be what you deserve.  So, accept your plight!  In the meantime, we elites will do our part to bar you from anything like upward social mobility.  Sorry, but our national interest does not include much of anything that's good for you.

  • jenjefer
    Posted: Sat, 12/10/2016 03:57 pm

    I'm shocked to hear that CI spends so little of its resources on sharing the Gospel of Jesus Christ. I knew that World Vision had caved in this area, but not Compassion.

    And the ones sharing Christ are called "black sheep?" By whom, the Indian Govt? If it's the officials at Compassion, shame on them. 

    They'd also better change their advertising, because they explicitly claim that they share the Gospel with each sponsored child.

  • VT
    Posted: Tue, 01/03/2017 06:39 pm

    Maybe they do...