Skip to main content

Notebook Religion

Prophetic error

(Associated Press/Photo by Douglas C. Pizac)

Associated Press/Photo by Jae C. Hong

Pippa Evans and Sanderson Jones


Prophetic error

LDS says early leaders were wrong on race

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS) has issued a major statement explaining racial policies that once banned black men from the Mormon priesthood, and that excluded all African-Americans from Mormon temples. Although LDS officials rescinded these prohibitions in 1978, the church had never fully addressed their historical roots.

“Race and the Priesthood” acknowledges that the bans came about under Brigham Young and other leaders, emerging in the context of pervasive 19th-century racism that “influenced all aspects of people’s lives, including their religion.” The biblical justifications often cited for the ethnic restrictions reflected “widespread ideas about racial inferiority,” the statement says.

“Race and the Priesthood” represents a major transition for the church, especially because of Mormons’ belief in the prophetic authority of leaders such as Young. The statement implies that the racial exclusions were rooted in early Mormon leaders’ prejudices, not divine revelation.

Patrick Mason, the Hunter Chair of Mormon Studies at Claremont Graduate University, told me the announcement raises important questions for committed Mormons: What does it mean “that their prophets, who they believe receive revelation from God, could allow the ban to happen (and supported it either explicitly or implicitly for 125 years)? If God is leading the church through His prophets, why didn’t He step in and stop it?” Mason notes that Mormons have never technically considered their prophets infallible, but that this statement identifies a troubling case in which the prophets were certainly wrong.

Mason also commends the new pronouncement for acknowledging that the Mormon racial prohibition was not just about the priesthood, but about banning all blacks from temples, where “Mormonism’s highest rites (including marriage for eternity) take place.” 

Church of unbelief

Two British comedians who launched an “atheist church” called Sunday Assembly have generated a great deal of public discussion but are struggling to attract financial support. The founders, Pippa Evans and Sanderson Jones, are touring the United Kingdom, North America, and Australia, raising funds through a “crowdfunding campaign” to establish Sunday Assemblies across the English-speaking world. They initially set a goal of $800,000 with a December deadline, but recently announced that they were revising the target down to $100,000. As of Christmas, they had raised about $55,000. 

Evans and Jones opened the first Sunday Assembly, which they call “a godless congregation that celebrates life,” in London in January 2013. The movement has since garnered extensive media attention, with coverage by The New York Times and other outlets. The Associated Press described Los Angeles’ Sunday Assembly as an “atheist mega-church,” although religion writer Bobby Ross Jr. pointed out that the number of Los Angeles attendees (less than 500) fell far short of the conventional megachurch definition of 2,000 congregants or more.

Alice Robb, writing for The New Republic, attended the inaugural meeting of Washington, D.C.’s Sunday Assembly. She reported that participants sang rock anthems by Queen and Bon Jovi, with Jones telling the audience that “for the next hour we’re just gonna celebrate the amazing fact that we are alive.” 

Some existing religions, such as Unitarian Universalism, balk at doctrinal certainty about God, but the Sunday Assemblies take a different approach. Jones and Evans say they accept people of all beliefs, but they have no deity and “don’t do supernatural.” One guest at the D.C. meeting told Robb the Universalists are “not the next new thing.” —T.K.


You must be a WORLD Member and logged in to the website to comment.
  • Bob Tozier
    Posted: Mon, 04/11/2016 03:59 pm

    So, now the Mormon church has explained its decision 35 years ago to remove its ban of blacks from its temples. However, the church continues to prohibit attendance of Christians--even parents--at the weddings of their Mormon children. Mormon prophets initiated, enforced, and removed the ban on blacks. They initiated and enforce today the ban of Christians (and others) from family weddings. When will they acknowledge this family-damaging prophetic error and reverse it?

  • Midwest preacher
    Posted: Mon, 04/11/2016 03:59 pm

    Two contrasting stories which illustrate the problems of man centered faith.  On one extreme men were given authority which  should have been left with God and on the other extreme are two people who deny that God can have any dealings with man because he (God) does not exist. Either system is a heavy load to drag around.